|
|
Short Title
|
Principal Act or Order
|
BNIL Citation or Year
|
Lands Tribunal Reference
|
Property Location
|
Main Issue
|
Other or Subsidiary Issue
|
Significant Other Issues or Legislation
|
|
Allister & Anr v Kerr
|
PO78
|
[1982] 3/61
|
R/1/1981
|
Bachelor's Walk, Lisburn
|
Compensation
|
Modification
|
Practical benefit; Valuation date; Downlift for historic values.
|
|
McCarney v Martin
|
PO78
|
[1989] 1/106
|
R/18/1988
|
Gilnahirk Rd, Belfast
|
Compensation
|
Modification
|
Compensation for bargaining power; Uplift for current values
|
|
Queen's University
|
PO78
|
[1990] 10/44
|
R/21/1990
|
Derryvolgie House, Malone, Belfast
|
Extinguishment
|
Unreasonable
|
Unit
|
|
Houston v DOE
|
AER71
|
[1990] 10/5
|
R/22/1990
|
Eglinton
|
Trees
|
Directions
|
|
|
Hamill
|
LE71
|
[1990] 7/86
|
R/43/1989
|
Hazelbank Rd, Ballymena
|
Conveyance
|
Registrar
|
|
|
Laing & Hurley
|
PO78
|
[1990] 7/87
|
R/37/1989
|
Kinnegar Rd, Holywood
|
Modification
|
Unreasonable
|
|
|
Nicholas
|
PO78
|
[1990] 7/88
|
R/36/1989
|
Derryvolgie Av, Belfast
|
Extinguishment
|
Unreasonable
|
Repairing
|
|
Gillespie v Trustees Portadown Masonic Hall
|
PO78
|
[1991] 1/66
|
R/18/1991
|
Carleton St, Portadown
|
Leave
|
Recent
|
|
|
Doyle v DOE
|
WS73
|
[1990] 2/60
|
R/7/1989
|
Castledawson
|
Sewerage Scheme
|
Compensation
|
|
|
Joel Ltd & McKinstry v Jamison
|
PO78
|
[1991] 1/74
|
R/45/1988
|
Downview Pk, Greenisland
|
Benefit
|
Modification
|
Unreasonable; Specific
|
|
Pedlow
|
PO78
|
[1991] 1/77
|
R/9/1992
|
Dunkirk Rd, Waringstown
|
Modification
|
Obsolete
|
Trust
|
|
Gallagher v DOE
|
RD80
|
[1991] 2/62
|
R/25/1989
|
Ballymagroary, Londonderry
|
Compensation
|
Betterment
|
Existing use
|
|
Loughran
|
LE71
|
[1991] 2/66
|
R/17/1990
|
Main St, Keady
|
Purchase Price
|
Registrar
|
|
|
Smyth v Clark & Rankin
|
PO78
|
[1991] 5/72
|
R/13/1991
|
William St, Bellaghy
|
Easement
|
Nature & extent
|
Jurisdiction; extinguishment
|
|
Graham v NIHE
|
HO81
|
[1991] 6/66
|
R/48/1990
|
Colchester St, Belfast
|
Occupier
|
Family
|
Site value
|
|
White v DOE
|
RD80
|
[1991] 7/125
|
R/9/1989
|
Dundooan, Coleraine
|
Flooding
|
Statutory powers
|
Exercise
|
|
Neill v Reps Gray
|
LE71
|
[1991] 7/129
|
R/29/1990
|
Kells
|
Conveyance
|
Execution
|
Registrar
|
|
Galbraith v DOE
|
LC82
|
[1991] 8/59
|
R/21/1989
|
Irwin Av, Belfast
|
Compensation
|
Possession
|
See [1996] 4/60 - R/19/1995
|
|
Swann v DOE
|
RD80
|
[1991] 9/75
|
R/31/1989
|
Dunsilly Rd, Antrim
|
Jurisdiction
|
Transfer of land
|
RD48
|
|
O'Brien v DANI
|
DO73
|
[1991] 9/76
|
R/46/1990
|
Caledon
|
River
|
Erosion
|
Compensation
|
|
Barbour & Payne v DANI
|
DO73
|
[1990] 7/85
|
R/2/1988
|
Bridge St, Comber
|
Flooding
|
Damage
|
Set off
|
|
Butler v NIHE
|
LC82
|
[1990] 8/37
|
R/30/1988
|
Eia St, Belfast
|
Possession
|
Mortgagee
|
|
|
Eccles & Ors v NIHE (1)
|
LC82
|
[1990] 9/54
|
R/38/1988
|
Park St, Coleraine
|
Basis of compensation
|
Unfit house
|
LAC73; HO81; prospects of possession; licencees
|
|
Stewart v Gorman & Cotton, Turnbull & Watt
|
LE71
|
[1992] 7/56
|
R/40/1991
|
Mill Pk, Ballymena
|
Notice
|
Service
|
Residential qualification
|
|
Eccles & Ors v NIHE (2)
|
LC82
|
[1991] 2/63
|
R/38/1988
|
Park St, Coleraine
|
No scheme world
|
Planning assumptions
|
|
|
Clarke
|
PO78
|
[1993] 1/77
|
R/44/1991
|
Deerpark Rd, Belfast
|
Modification
|
Unreasonable
|
|
|
Carney v DOE
|
WS73
|
[1994] 4/62
|
R/14/1992
|
Devon Ct, Rathenraw
|
Jurisdiction
|
Execution of works
|
MD69; LG72
|
|
Neeson v DOE
|
RD80
|
[1994] 2/81
|
R/8/1991
|
Church St, Dromore
|
Injurious affection
|
Betterment
|
|
|
Erwin & Anr
|
LE71
|
[1995] 1/42
|
R/6/1993
|
Kinhilt St, Ballymena
|
Residential qualification
|
Purchase price
|
Paid into Court; Registrar
|
|
Bell & Ors v Nixon & Ors
|
PO78
|
[1995] 2/42
|
R/11/1994
|
Hamilton Rd, Bangor
|
Unreasonable
|
Practical benefit
|
Nominal compensation
|
|
Farquharson & Ors
|
PO78
|
[1995] 2/43
|
R/1/1994
|
Station Rd, Craigavad
|
Modification
|
Unreasonable
|
No compensation
|
|
Andrews v Davis
|
PO78
|
[1995] 3/81
|
R/17/1993
|
The Dub Stores, Belfast
|
Benefit
|
Unreasonable
|
Public interest; practical benefit; profit motive; liquor licence; compensation
|
|
Browne Ltd v DOE
|
RD80
|
[1990] 9/55
|
R/16/1987
|
Dublin Rd
|
Valuation method
|
Residual
|
Comparable; RT81
|
|
Napier & Sons
|
PO78
|
[1992] 7/58
|
R/8/1992
|
Upton Cottages, Belfast
|
Extinguishment
|
Unreasonable
|
|
|
Rev Cromie & Ors
|
PO78
|
[1992] 7/59
|
R/23/1991
|
Fort Lands, Hilden
|
Extinguishment
|
Unreasonable
|
Objectors
|
|
Ulster Friends Trustees Ltd
|
PO78
|
[1992] 7/59
|
R/6/1992
|
Richhill
|
Extinguishment
|
Unreasonable
|
|
|
Mullan & Ors
|
PO78
|
[1993] 1/77
|
R/20/1992
|
Antrim Rd, Newtownabbey
|
Modification
|
Unreasonable
|
Trust
|
|
Todd v Unwin & Ors
|
LE71
|
[1993] 2/90
|
R/16/1992
|
Avondale Dr, Ballyclare
|
Assignment
|
Intention
|
Scope; sub-lease upheld on Appeal - see [1994] 7/71
|
|
Crossan v DOE
|
RT81
|
[1993] 6/64
|
R/5/1992
|
Mill St, Comber
|
Damage
|
Road closure
|
WS73; private right
|
|
Clarke v Black
|
LE71
|
[1993] 8/48
|
R/29/1992
|
Portaferry Rd, Newtownards
|
Valuation
|
|
|
|
McKee & Ors v O'Callaghan
|
PO78
|
[1995] 3/81
|
R/13/1993
|
Ogle St, Armagh
|
Modification
|
Unreasonable
|
Liquor licence
|
|
Armagh Diocesan Board of Education
|
PO78
|
[1995] 4/73
|
R/13/1994
|
Carrickmore, Co Tyrone
|
Modification
|
Obsolete
|
Former school & house; church hall; compensation
|
|
Haslett v DOE
|
LAC73
|
[1995] 5/62
|
R/18/1993
|
Upper Knockbreda Rd, Belfast
|
Depreciation
|
Physical factors
|
Burden; expert evidence
|
|
Bell v Ker
|
LE71
|
[1995] 8/41
|
R/16/1994
|
Main St, Ballynahinch
|
By reason of
|
Strict interpretation
|
Expropriator; right attached to land; technicalities
|
|
Napier v Nurse
|
PO78
|
[1996] 2/59
|
R/1/1996
|
Earlswood Rd, Belfast
|
Costs
|
Withdrawal
|
Academic
|
|
Donnelly v NIHE
|
LC82
|
[1996] 3/56
|
R/12/1995
|
Benares St, Belfast
|
Market value
|
Expert evidence
|
Sales and settlements
|
|
Clancy Ltd & Ors v Presbyterian Widow's
|
PO78
|
[1996] 3/57
|
R/34/1995
|
Ravenscroft Av, Belfast
|
Modification
|
Practical benefit
|
|
|
Corry v Hall/Kennedy Estate
|
PO78
|
[1996] 3/58
|
R/46/1995
|
Cultra
|
Benefit
|
Practical benefit
|
|
|
Lunney v NIHE
|
LC82
|
[1996] 4/60
|
R/19/1995
|
Cupar St, Belfast
|
Prospect of possession
|
Duty to rehouse
|
Gailbraith v DOE [1991] 8/59 not followed; AL19; LAC73
|
|
Neilson v NIHE
|
LC82
|
[1996] 4/61
|
R/13/1995
|
Dunmore St, Belfast
|
Disturbance
|
Mortgage indemnity premium
|
Decoration
|
|
Hay & Ors
|
PO78
|
[1996] 4/63
|
R/36/1995
|
Victoria Hall, Londonderry
|
Extinguishment
|
Benefits & burdens
|
Unreasonable
|
|
R McIlroy & Ors
|
PO78
|
[1996] 4/63
|
R/15/1996
|
Raloo
|
Extinguishment
|
Unreasonable
|
Trust
|
|
McIntyre v DOE
|
PO91
|
[1996] 9/67
|
R/19/1992 & R/4/1994
|
Arcadia Portrush
|
Compensation
|
Market value
|
LG72; LC82; expert's role; costs; purchase notice
|
|
Greer v NIHE
|
LAC73
|
[1997] 10/56
|
R/19/1996
|
Rosewood St, Belfast
|
Disturbance
|
Expert evidence
|
Duty; transparency; intuitive approach
|
|
Lindberg v NIHE
|
LC82
|
[1997] 8/39
|
R/21/1995
|
Trallee St, Belfast
|
Disturbance
|
Mortgage interest
|
Set off; LG72
|
|
Multiple Sclerosis Society
|
PO78
|
[1997] 8/40
|
R/16/1997
|
Annadale Av, Belfast
|
Benefit
|
Modification
|
Compensation
|
|
Hawe v NIHE
|
LC82
|
[1998] 6/64
|
R/19/1997
|
Albertville Dr, Belfast
|
Market value
|
Expert evidence
|
Transparency; sales and settlements
|
|
Ross v Johnston (1)
|
PO78
|
[2000] 2/57
|
R/35/1998
|
Upper Rd, Greenisland
|
Leave
|
Original coventaor
|
Effect; fee farm grant
|
|
Brady v NIHE
|
LC82
|
[2001] 5/94
|
R/41/1999
|
Spamount St, Belfast
|
Disturbance
|
Causal connection
|
New house; legal costs; intention
|
|
Connon v DOE
|
RD93
|
[2001] 5/97
|
R/41/1998
|
Queen St, Ballymena
|
Development site
|
Liquor licence
|
Valuation method LO90
|
|
Danesfort v Morrow & Palmer (1)
|
PO78
|
[2001] 6/89
|
R/45/1999
|
Stranmillis Rd, Belfast
|
Benefit
|
Adjoining land
|
|
|
Walkington v Orr
|
PO78
|
[2001] 6/90
|
R/4/2000
|
Portavogie
|
Costs
|
Withdrawal
|
Right of way
|
|
Tesco
|
PO78
|
[2001] 1/42
|
R/50/1999
|
Orritor Rd, Cookstown
|
Modification
|
Trustees
|
Sunday trading, liquor licence
|
|
Conville & Anr (1)
|
PO78
|
[2002] 2/70
|
R/64/2000
|
Carney Hill, Craigavad
|
Benefit
|
Restrictive
|
Scheme; positive
|
|
Milligan v DOE
|
PO72
|
[2002] 4/54
|
R/25/1997
|
Edenaclough Wood, Fermanagh
|
Admissibility of expert evidence
|
Prospect of planning permission
|
PO91
|
|
Danesfort v Morrow & Palmer (2)
|
PO78
|
[2002] 4/55
|
R/45/1999
|
Stranmillis Rd, Belfast
|
Modification
|
Practical benefit
|
Amenity & character; privacy & seclusion; planning permission
|
|
Conville & Anr (2)
|
PO78
|
[2002] 2/70
|
R/64/2000
|
Carney Hill, Craigavad
|
Modification
|
Impact
|
Bungalow; sea view
|
|
Eircom v Dynan
|
PO78
|
[2001]
|
R/67/2000
|
Diamond Gdns, Finaghy
|
Objectors
|
Development scheme
|
|
|
Maguire v DOE
|
LC82
|
[1992]
|
R/10/1992
|
Rossole Rd, Enniskillen
|
Market value
|
Disturbance
|
Garden
|
|
McDonald v Geddis & Hobson
|
PO78
|
[2000]
|
R/35/1999
|
Warren Rd, Donaghadee
|
Costs
|
Late withdrawal
|
|
|
McKeag v NIHE
|
LC82
|
[1999]
|
R/36/1998
|
Rosewood St, Belfast
|
Compensation
|
Market value
|
Comparables; settlements; market transactions
|
|
McNicholl v Mullan & Anr
|
PO78
|
[2001]
|
R/49/1999
|
Chapel Hill, Cookstown
|
Jurisdiction
|
Blank cheque
|
Nature & extent; trade or business; restraint of trade; admissibility
|
|
Ashfield v Lowe
|
PO78
|
[2005] 1/66
|
R/35/2000
|
Tyrone
|
Costs
|
Assessment
|
|
|
McMahon & Anr v Kingsmoat (1)
|
PO78
|
[2003] 7/66
|
R/40/2002 & R/41/2002
|
Kings Rd, Belfast
|
Whether impediment
|
Business profitability
|
Self certification
|
|
Ross v Johnston (2)
|
PO78
|
[2002] 2/57
|
R/35/1998
|
Upper Rd, Greenisland
|
Costs
|
Proportion
|
Conduct
|
|
Bunting v NIHE
|
LC82
|
[2003] 10/91
|
R/53/2002
|
Rathlin St, Belfast
|
Disturbance
|
Fees
|
LAC73
|
|
Castlereagh BC v NIHE
|
PO78
|
[2003]
|
R/30/2002 & R/32/2002
|
Ballyhanwood, Belfast
|
Compensation
|
Indexation
|
RPI
|
|
Ward & Anr v NIHE (1)
|
PO78
|
[2004] 2/65
|
< | |
