Short Title

Principal Act or Order

BNIL Citation or Year

Lands Tribunal Reference

Property Location

Main Issue

Other or Subsidiary Issue

Significant Other Issues or Legislation

Allister & Anr v Kerr

PO78

[1982] 3/61

R/1/1981

Bachelor's Walk, Lisburn

Compensation

Modification

Practical benefit; Valuation date; Downlift for historic values.

McCarney v Martin

PO78

[1989] 1/106

R/18/1988

Gilnahirk Rd, Belfast

Compensation

Modification

Compensation for bargaining power; Uplift for current values

Queen's University

PO78

[1990] 10/44

R/21/1990

Derryvolgie House, Malone, Belfast

Extinguishment

Unreasonable

Unit

Houston v DOE

AER71

[1990] 10/5

R/22/1990

Eglinton

Trees

Directions

Hamill

LE71

[1990] 7/86

R/43/1989

Hazelbank Rd, Ballymena

Conveyance

Registrar

Laing & Hurley

PO78

[1990] 7/87

R/37/1989

Kinnegar Rd, Holywood

Modification

Unreasonable

Nicholas

PO78

[1990] 7/88

R/36/1989

Derryvolgie Av, Belfast

Extinguishment

Unreasonable

Repairing

Gillespie v Trustees Portadown Masonic Hall

PO78

[1991] 1/66

R/18/1991

Carleton St, Portadown

Leave

Recent

Doyle v DOE

WS73

[1990] 2/60

R/7/1989

Castledawson

Sewerage Scheme

Compensation

Joel Ltd & McKinstry v Jamison

PO78

[1991] 1/74

R/45/1988

Downview Pk, Greenisland

Benefit

Modification

Unreasonable;  Specific

Pedlow

PO78

[1991] 1/77

R/9/1992

Dunkirk Rd, Waringstown

Modification

Obsolete

Trust

Gallagher v DOE

RD80

[1991] 2/62

R/25/1989

Ballymagroary, Londonderry

Compensation

Betterment

Existing use

Loughran

LE71

[1991] 2/66

R/17/1990

Main St, Keady

Purchase Price

Registrar

Smyth v Clark & Rankin

PO78

[1991] 5/72

R/13/1991

William St, Bellaghy

Easement

Nature & extent

Jurisdiction;  extinguishment

Graham v NIHE

HO81

[1991] 6/66

R/48/1990

Colchester St, Belfast

Occupier

Family

Site value

White v DOE

RD80

[1991] 7/125

R/9/1989

Dundooan, Coleraine

Flooding

Statutory powers

Exercise

Neill v Reps Gray

LE71

[1991] 7/129

R/29/1990

Kells

Conveyance

Execution

Registrar

Galbraith v DOE

LC82

[1991] 8/59

R/21/1989

Irwin Av, Belfast

Compensation

Possession

See [1996] 4/60 - R/19/1995

Swann v DOE

RD80

[1991] 9/75

R/31/1989

Dunsilly Rd, Antrim

Jurisdiction

Transfer of land

RD48

O'Brien v DANI

DO73

[1991] 9/76

R/46/1990

Caledon

River

Erosion

Compensation

Barbour & Payne v DANI

DO73

[1990] 7/85

R/2/1988

Bridge St, Comber

Flooding

Damage

Set off

Butler v NIHE

LC82

[1990] 8/37

R/30/1988

Eia St, Belfast

Possession

Mortgagee

Eccles & Ors v NIHE (1)

LC82

[1990] 9/54

R/38/1988

Park St, Coleraine

Basis of compensation

Unfit house

LAC73; HO81;  prospects of possession;  licencees

Stewart v Gorman & Cotton, Turnbull & Watt

LE71

[1992] 7/56

R/40/1991

Mill Pk, Ballymena

Notice

Service

Residential qualification

Eccles & Ors v NIHE (2)

LC82

[1991] 2/63

R/38/1988

Park St, Coleraine

No scheme world

Planning assumptions

Clarke

PO78

[1993] 1/77

R/44/1991

Deerpark Rd, Belfast

Modification

Unreasonable

Carney v DOE

WS73

[1994] 4/62

R/14/1992

Devon Ct, Rathenraw

Jurisdiction

Execution of works

MD69;  LG72

Neeson v DOE

RD80

[1994] 2/81

R/8/1991

Church St, Dromore

Injurious affection

Betterment

Erwin & Anr

LE71

[1995] 1/42

R/6/1993

Kinhilt St, Ballymena

Residential qualification

Purchase price

Paid into Court; Registrar

Bell & Ors v Nixon & Ors

PO78

[1995] 2/42

R/11/1994

Hamilton Rd, Bangor

Unreasonable

Practical benefit

Nominal compensation

Farquharson & Ors

PO78

[1995] 2/43

R/1/1994

Station Rd, Craigavad

Modification

Unreasonable

No compensation

Andrews v Davis

PO78

[1995] 3/81

R/17/1993

The Dub Stores, Belfast

Benefit

Unreasonable

Public interest; practical benefit; profit motive;  liquor licence; compensation

Browne Ltd v DOE

RD80

[1990] 9/55

R/16/1987

Dublin Rd

Valuation method

Residual

Comparable;  RT81

Napier & Sons

PO78

[1992] 7/58

R/8/1992

Upton Cottages, Belfast

Extinguishment

Unreasonable

Rev Cromie & Ors

PO78

[1992] 7/59

R/23/1991

Fort Lands, Hilden

Extinguishment

Unreasonable

Objectors

Ulster Friends Trustees Ltd

PO78

[1992] 7/59

R/6/1992

Richhill

Extinguishment

Unreasonable

Mullan & Ors

PO78

[1993] 1/77

R/20/1992

Antrim Rd, Newtownabbey

Modification

Unreasonable

Trust

Todd v Unwin & Ors

LE71

[1993] 2/90

R/16/1992

Avondale Dr, Ballyclare

Assignment

Intention

Scope; sub-lease upheld on Appeal - see [1994] 7/71

Crossan v DOE

RT81

[1993] 6/64

R/5/1992

Mill St, Comber

Damage

Road closure

WS73;  private right

Clarke v Black

LE71

[1993] 8/48

R/29/1992

Portaferry Rd, Newtownards

Valuation

McKee & Ors v O'Callaghan

PO78

[1995] 3/81

R/13/1993

Ogle St, Armagh

Modification

Unreasonable

Liquor licence

Armagh Diocesan Board of Education

PO78

[1995] 4/73

R/13/1994

Carrickmore, Co Tyrone

Modification

Obsolete

Former school & house; church hall; compensation

Haslett v DOE

LAC73

[1995] 5/62

R/18/1993

Upper Knockbreda Rd, Belfast

Depreciation

Physical factors

Burden;  expert evidence

Bell v Ker

LE71

[1995] 8/41

R/16/1994

Main St, Ballynahinch

By reason of

Strict interpretation

Expropriator;  right attached to land;  technicalities

Napier v Nurse

PO78

[1996] 2/59

R/1/1996

Earlswood Rd, Belfast

Costs

Withdrawal

Academic

Donnelly v NIHE

LC82

[1996] 3/56

R/12/1995

Benares St, Belfast

Market value

Expert evidence

Sales and settlements

Clancy Ltd & Ors v Presbyterian Widow's

PO78

[1996] 3/57

R/34/1995

Ravenscroft Av, Belfast

Modification

Practical benefit

Corry v Hall/Kennedy Estate

PO78

[1996] 3/58

R/46/1995

Cultra

Benefit

Practical benefit

Lunney v NIHE

LC82

[1996] 4/60

R/19/1995

Cupar St, Belfast

Prospect of possession

Duty to rehouse

Gailbraith v DOE [1991] 8/59 not followed; AL19;  LAC73

Neilson v NIHE

LC82

[1996] 4/61

R/13/1995

Dunmore St, Belfast

Disturbance

Mortgage indemnity premium

Decoration

Hay & Ors

PO78

[1996] 4/63

R/36/1995

Victoria Hall, Londonderry

Extinguishment

Benefits & burdens

Unreasonable

R McIlroy & Ors

PO78

[1996] 4/63

R/15/1996

Raloo

Extinguishment

Unreasonable

Trust

McIntyre v DOE

PO91

[1996] 9/67

R/19/1992 & R/4/1994

Arcadia Portrush

Compensation

Market value

LG72;  LC82; expert's role;  costs;  purchase notice

Greer v NIHE

LAC73

[1997] 10/56

R/19/1996

Rosewood St, Belfast

Disturbance

Expert evidence

Duty;  transparency; intuitive approach

Lindberg v NIHE

LC82

[1997] 8/39

R/21/1995

Trallee St, Belfast

Disturbance

Mortgage interest

Set off; LG72

Multiple Sclerosis Society

PO78

[1997] 8/40

R/16/1997

Annadale Av, Belfast

Benefit

Modification

Compensation

Hawe v NIHE

LC82

[1998] 6/64

R/19/1997

Albertville Dr, Belfast

Market value

Expert evidence

Transparency;  sales and settlements

Ross v Johnston (1)

PO78

[2000] 2/57

R/35/1998

Upper Rd, Greenisland

Leave

Original coventaor

Effect;  fee farm grant

Brady v NIHE

LC82

[2001] 5/94

R/41/1999

Spamount St, Belfast

Disturbance

Causal connection

New house; legal costs; intention

Connon v DOE

RD93

[2001] 5/97

R/41/1998

Queen St, Ballymena

Development site

Liquor licence

Valuation method LO90

Danesfort v Morrow & Palmer (1)

PO78

[2001] 6/89

R/45/1999

Stranmillis Rd, Belfast

Benefit

Adjoining land

Walkington v Orr (1)

PO78

[2001] 6/90

R/4/2000

Portavogie

Costs

Withdrawal

Right of way

Tesco

PO78

[2001] 1/42

R/50/1999

Orritor Rd, Cookstown

Modification

Trustees

Sunday trading, liquor licence

Conville & Anr (1)

PO78

[2002] 2/70

R/64/2000

Carney Hill, Craigavad

Benefit

Restrictive

Scheme;  positive

Milligan v DOE

PO72

[2002] 4/54

R/25/1997

Edenaclough Wood, Fermanagh

Admissibility of expert evidence

Prospect of planning permission

PO91

Danesfort v Morrow & Palmer (2)

PO78

[2002] 4/55

R/45/1999

Stranmillis Rd, Belfast

Modification

Practical benefit

Amenity & character; privacy & seclusion; planning permission

Conville & Anr (2)

PO78

[2002] 2/70

R/64/2000

Carney Hill, Craigavad

Modification

Impact

Bungalow;  sea view

Eircom v Dynan

PO78

[2001]

R/67/2000

Diamond Gdns, Finaghy

Objectors

Development scheme

Maguire v DOE

LC82

[1992]

R/10/1992

Rossole Rd, Enniskillen

Market value

Disturbance

Garden

McDonald v Geddis & Hobson

PO78

[2000]

R/35/1999

Warren Rd, Donaghadee

Costs

Late withdrawal

McKeag v NIHE

LC82

[1999]

R/36/1998

Rosewood St, Belfast

Compensation

Market value

Comparables; settlements; market transactions

McNicholl v Mullan & Anr

PO78

[2001]

R/49/1999

Chapel Hill, Cookstown

Jurisdiction

Blank cheque

Nature & extent; trade or business; restraint of trade; admissibility

Ashfield v Lowe

PO78

[2005] 1/66

R/35/2000

Tyrone

Costs

Assessment

McMahon & Anr v Kingsmoat (1)

PO78

[2003] 7/66

R/40/2002 & R/41/2002

Kings Rd, Belfast

Whether impediment

Business profitability

Self certification

Ross v Johnston (2)

PO78

[2002] 2/57

R/35/1998

Upper Rd, Greenisland

Costs

Proportion

Conduct

Bunting v NIHE

LC82

[2003] 10/91

R/53/2002

Rathlin St, Belfast

Disturbance

Fees

LAC73

Castlereagh BC v NIHE

PO78

[2003]

R/30/2002 & R/32/2002

Ballyhanwood, Belfast

Compensation

Indexation

RPI

Ward & Anr v NIHE (1)

PO78

[2004] 2/65

R/16/2002

Old Dundonald Rd, Dundonald

Compensation

Holding

Comparables; unrestricted value;  marriage

McKillen v Ors v Ferguson & Anr (1)

PO78

[2003]

R/35/2002

Ashley Pk, Dunmurry

Modification

Premature

Road widening; density

Ward & Anr v NIHE (2)

PO78

[2004] 10/80

R/16/2002

Old Dundonald Rd, Dundonald

Costs

Curley & Ors v NIHE (1)

LC82

[2003] 5/62

R/1/2003 & R/5/2003

Cawnpore St & Clonard Gdns, Belfast

Disturbance

Legal costs

New house; delay

Bell v SEBHSS Trust (1)

LAC73

[2004] 9/60

R/10/2002

Lisburn Rd, Belfast

Jurisdiction

Disturbance

Curley & Ors v NIHE (2)

LC82

[2004] 8/53

R/1-2/2003 & R/5/2003

Disturbance

Causal connection

Solicitors costs

Spruce v Palmer

PO78

[2004]

R/63/2003

Danesfort, Stranmillis Rd, Belfast

PLV

Implied agreement

See also R/45/1999 Parts 1 & 2

Nobel v NIHE

LC82

[2004] 8/52

R/8/2004

Glasgow St, Belfast

Disturbance

Equivalence

Garden shed

Maxol v DOE

LG72

[2004]

R/60/1999

The Harbour, Carrickfergus

Non-occupation

Equivalence

Solus agreement PO 91

Watt v NIHE (1)

LC82

[2004]

R/21/2002

Euston Parade, Belfast

Tenancy

Protected tenancy

Rent (NI) Order 1978;  Housing (NI) Order 1983

McGrath & Anr v O'Neill & Ors (1)

PO78

[2005] 4/88

R/41/2004

Coleraine Rd, Portstewart

Compensation

Breach

Conduct

O'Neill & Ors v NIHE

LC82

[2005]

R/2, 3 & 4/2004

Havana Gdns, Belfast

Disturbance

Fees

LAC73

McKillen & Ors v Ferguson & Anr (2)

PO78

[2005] 7/91

R/35/2002

Ashley Pk, Dunmurry

Costs

Application

Time

Bell v SEBHSS Trust (2)

LAC73

[2005]

R/10/2002

Lisburn Rd, Belfast

Costs

Compulsory Acquisition

McMahon & Anr v Kingsmoat (2)

PO78

[2003]

R/40/2002 & R/41/2002

Kings Rd, Belfast

Costs

Proportionate award

Subsidiary questions

Mulholland v NIHE (1)

LC82

[2005] 9/75

R/48/2004

Gainsborough Dr, Belfast

Compensation

McGrath & Anr v O'Neill & Ors (2)

PO78

[2005] 10/78

R/41/2004

Coleraine Rd, Portstewart

Costs

Offers

Conduct

McCreesh v NIHE

LAC73

[2005] 3/73

R/26/2003

Stewartstown Rd, Belfast

Jurisdiction

Disturbance

Mulholland & Anr v Invest NI

LC82

[2006] 6/76

R/46/2005

Blackpark Rd, Toomebridge

Compensation

Planning

Roads

Oaklee v Lynas

PO78

[2006]

R/62/2004

Rosetta Av, Belfast

Breach

Modification

Lessor's discretion

Watt v NIHE (2)

LC82

[2006] 7/70

R/21/2002

Euston Parade, Belfast

Costs

Amount

Eastonville v Gillespie & Ors (1)

PO78

[2007]

R/41/2006

Holborn Av, Bangor

Whether impediment

Interpretation of agreement

Mulholland v NIHE (2)

LC82

[2007] 9/78

R/48/2004

Gainsborough Dr, Belfast

Costs

Spanboard v The Crown

PO78

[2007] 9/78

R/56/2004

Costs

McCann v DSD

LC82

[2008] 1/51

R/67/2004

Cornmarket, Belfast

Costs

Wilson v DRD

PBO81

[2008] 4/73

R/13/1996

Ballynure Rd, Newtownabbey

Costs

Blight Notice

Hewitt & Ors v O'Neill & Ors

PO78

[2008]

R/17/2006

Cleaver Av, Cleaver Gdns & Cleaver Pk, Belfast

Benefit

Building Scheme

Ground Rents Act (NI) 2001

Glenwherry v NIHE

PLCA71

[1974]

R/5/1974

Shaftesbury Sq, Belfast

Blight

Qualifiying interest

Hyde Ltd v DOE

PLCA71

[1974]

R/6/1974

Armagh Rd, Portadown

Blight

Appropriate authority

Benner v NIHE

PLCA71

[1977]

R/11/1974

Donegall Pass, Belfast

Blight

Occupation

McLean v NIHE

PLCA71

[1976]

R/17/1974

Ormeau Rd, Belfast

Blight

Licence

Hill v DOE

PLCA71

[1975]

R/12/1975

Glencraig Pk, Craigavad

Blight

Material detriment

McGonigal v DOE

PLCA71

[1975]

R/18/1975

Hawthornden Rd, Belfast

Blight

Valuation date

Interest

Pantridge v DOE

PLCA71

[1977]

R/1/1977

Collin House, Dunmurry

Blight

Material detriment

Jeffers v DOE

PLCA71

[1977]

R/7/1977

Donegall Rd, Belfast

Blight

Reasonable endeavours

Churches' Youth Welfare Council v DOE

PLCA71

[1977]

R/9/1977

Blythe St, Belfast

Blight

Reasonable endeavours

Mitchell v DOE

PLCA71

[1978]

R/18/1977

Charles St, Lurgan

Blight

No proposal

Eastwood v DOE

PLCA71

[1983]

R/30/1982

Fountain Rd, Cookstown

Blight

Second notice

MacRae v DOE

PLCA71

[1985]

R/30/1983

Donegall Rd, Belfast

Blight

Disturbance

S D Bell v DOE

RD48

[1988]

R/1/1987

Upper Newtownards Rd, Belfast

Tenancy

Compensatable interest

Limitation

Salvation Army v DOE

PLCA71

[1987]

R/4/1987

Oldpark Rd, Belfast

Blight

Time limit

see R/5/1988

Salvation Army v DOE

PLCA71

[1988]

R/5/1988

Oldpark Rd, Belfast

Blight

Time limit

see R/4/1987

Scalene v DSD

LC82

[2008]

R/30/2005

Ann St & Upper Church Lane, Belfast

Market value

Rent

Scheme

Davies & Anr v Greene

PO78

[2009] 6/70

R/11/2008

Jordanstown Rd, Newtownabbey

Costs

Withdrawal

Brooks v NIHE

LAC73

[2009]

R/27/2007

Alexandra Pk Av, Belfast

Costs

Premature

Ryde's Scale

Cotter & Anr v DRD

PBO81

[2009]

R/33/2008

Shore Rd, Greenisland

Costs

Withdrawal

Kamack v Stinson & Anr

PO78

[2009]

R/52/2007

Prospect Rd, Portstewart

Modification

Neighbour

Drayne v St Patrick's Trust

PO78

[2009]

Jockey Lane, Moy

Modification

Neighbour

Howard King & Partners v DSD

LGA72

[2009]

Montgomery St, Belfast

Withdrawal

Costs

Treacy v Down DC

LAC73

[2009] 10/82

R/15/2005

Killough Port, Killough

Limitation

Waiver 

Limitation (NI) Order 1989

Short Title

Principal Act or Order

BNIL Citation or Year

Lands Tribunal Reference

Property Location

Main Issue

Other or Subsidiary Issue

Significant Other Issues or Legislation

Harte v Hughes

BTA64

[1990] 1/55

BT/71/1989

George's St, Dungannon

Notice

Validity

Opposition;  own use:  later date

Clancy v Wine Inns Ltd

BTA64

[1990] 1/54

BT/79/1989

Winetavern St, Belfast

Termination date

McGovern v Cathcart

BTA64

[1990] 1/55

BT/63/1989

Tempo Rd, Enniskillen

Opposition

Own use

Later date

Fee v Raymill

BTA64

[1990] 10/43

BT/54/1990

Townhall St, Enniskillen

Opposition

Rent

Carlin v Scotch-Irish Trust

BTA64

[1990] 5/70

BT/117/1989

Ulster-American Folk Park, Tyrone

Opposition

Works

Own use

Richardson v Toal

BTA64

[1990] 5/71

G/15

Validity of Notice

Time limits

McEntee & Ors v Her Jiung Jan

BTO96

[1990] 9/56

BT/37/1989

Antrim Rd, Belfast

Opposition

Rent

Ready Mixed Concrete v McCaffrey (1)

BTA64

[1991] 3/71

BT/63/1990

Kelvin Rd, Omagh

Opposition

Intention

Other breaches;  proposed sale; see [1992] 1/63

Connolly v Crossmaglen Credit Union

BTA64

[1991] 7/126

BT/111/1990

The Square, Crossmaglen

Opposition

Rent

Alternative accommodation

Joyland Amusements v A S & D Enterprises

BTA64

[1991] 7/127

BT/102/1989

North St, Belfast

Validity of Notice

Contents

Service

Sally v Michaux & Ors

BTA64

[1991] 7/128

BT/79/1990

John St, Omagh

New tenancy

Duration

Rent

Boyd v Foreman

BTA64

[1997] 2/51

BT/12/1993

Fountain St, Belfast

Opposition

Duration

Back door; estoppel;  scope of evidence

Oxfam v Earl & Ors

BTA64

[1997] 3/71

BT/3/1995

The Diamond, Coleraine

Costs

Offer

Calderbank

Priestly v Brown

BTO96

[1997] 5/52

BT/8/1996

Antrim Rd, Ballynahinch

Withdrawal

Terms

Harvey v Schofield & Anderson

BTO96

[1998] 1/53

BT/27/1998

Ravara Rd, Ballygowan

Tenancy application

Time limit

Degree of default; effect

Campbells v Scottish Provident

BTO96

[1998] 10/59

BT/33/1998

Donegall Sq, Belfast

Renewal

User

Tribunal's discretion

Sekhri v Millar (1)

BTO96

[1998] 2/56

BT/97/1996

Church St, Ballymena

Opposition

Rent

Future conduct

Sekhri v Millar (2)

BTO96

[1998] 2/57

BT/97/1996

Church St, Ballymena

Jurisdiction

Control of case

Postponement of Order

Save Service Station v Ravenseft

BTA64

[1998] 6/64

BT/37/1996

Ards Shopping Centre

Renewal

Rent

Costs; offer

Kerr & Ors v ABC Credit Union

BTO96

[1999] 10/40

BT/30/1998

Crumlin Rd, Belfast

Counter notice

Notice to Determine

Reasonable recipient

Campbell v Finegan

BTO96

[1999] 4/59

BT/57/1998

High St, Bangor

Costs

Allocation

Evidence of negotiations

Rainey v Rogers Ltd

BTO96

[1999] 9/56

BT/36/1999

Saintfield Rd, Belfast

Opposition

Other reasons

Parking regulation

NIHE v Extravision

BTO96

[2000] 6/59

BT/60/1999

Castlereagh Rd, Belfast

Costs

Cards on the table

Event

McCandless v Lynch

BTO96

[2001] 4/65

BT/65/2000

Andersonstown Rd, Belfast

Opposition

Intention

Own use

Ready Mixed Concrete v McCaffrey (2)

BTA64

[1992] 1/63

BT/63/1990

Kelvin Rd, Omagh

Duration

Rent

Restricted user; see [1991] 3/71

Murphy v Gregory

BTA64

[1992] 4/76

BT/62/1991

Camlough, Newry

Notice

Validity

Opposition;  obligations

Sharma v McHugh

BTA64

[1992] 4/77

BT/88/1991

Castle Pl, Strabane

Opposition

Intention

Own use; 5 year

Watson v King

BTA64

[1992] 5/73

BT/129/1991

High St, Holywood

Opposition

Rent

Repair

Riverside Snooker Club v Lamont (Holdings)

BTA64

[1992] 5/74

BT/65/1991

Riverside Factory, Antrim

Validity of Notice

Service

Election;  contents

Johnston (Samuel) Ltd & Devenney v Andras House

BTA64

[1992] 5/75

BT/123, 124 & 125/1991

Great Victoria St, Belfast

Validity of Notice

Time limits

Sawyers v Nesbitt

BTA64

[1992] 8/55

BT/52/1992

Hamilton Rd, Bangor

Opposition

Rent

Cosgrove v Cathcart

BTA64

[1993] 9/54

BT/31/1993

Derrychara, Enniskillen

Opposition

Intention

Rent & interest

Taggart v McIlwaine

BTA64

[1994] 1/71

BT/97/1993

Ballymena Rd, Larne

Notice

Validity

Competent landlord

Corey v Donnelly & Brennan

BTA64

[1994] 5/71

BT/76/1993

Burn Rd, Cookstown

Opposition

Rent

Other terms

McDevitte v McKillop

BTA64

[1994] 5/71

BT/101/1993

University Av, Belfast

Opposition

Own use

Decision overturned on Appeal - see [1995] 1/41

Kin Leung Yuen v McHugh & Ors

BTA64

[1994] 7/70

BT/35/1994

Springfield Rd, Belfast

Counter notice

Validity

Grounds

Stewarts Supermarkets v Dunwoody

BTA64

[1994] 9/75

BT/109/1993

Bridge St, Banbridge

Opposition

Works

Intention

Maxim Video v Delargy

BTA64

[1994] 9/76

BT/78/1992

Castle St, Antrim

Withdrawal

Delay

Rent

Douglas v Hunter

BTA64

[1996] 4/63

BT/9/1995

Bridge St, Lisburn

Opposition

Renovation provision

Option

Age Concern v Irish Society

BTO96

[2001] 9/62

BT/95/2000

Waterside, Coleraine

Compensation

Costs

Young v Boyd

BTO96

[2002] 2/68

BT/11/2001

Fountain St, Antrim

Business purposes

Occupation

Abandonment

Thompson v Cawoods

BTO96

[2001]

BT/72/2000

Main St, Scarva

Scope

Business occupation

Graham v Dunloe  Ewart

BTO96

[2002] 7/47

BT/24/2000

Garfield St, Belfast

Duration

Break Clause

Redevelopment; compulsory purchase; bookmaking licence;  BGLA85

Orr & Anr v Buchanan

BTO96

[2002] 8/51

BT/34/2002

Market St, Portadown

Termination date

Costs

Fujitsu v Brunswick (1)

BTO96

[2003] 1/70

BT/90/2002

Lanyon Pl, Belfast

Alienation consent

Default insurance

Rent shortfall;  cap on service charge

Fujitsu v Brunswick (2)

BTO96

[2003] 8/74

BT/90/2002

Lanyon Pl, Belfast

Costs

Intertwined issues

Skelton v McEvoy (1)

BTO96

[2003] 4/77, 7/67

BT/72/2001

Antrim Rd, Belfast

Rent

Analysis of comparables

Objective interpretation;  primary & secondary effects; restricted user; post relevant date transactions;  interest on rent

Eason v Craigavon

BTO96

[2003] 7/67

BT/80/2001

Rushmere, Craigavon

Break clause

End allowance

Size

Supervalu v Ervine

BTO96

[2003] 8/73

BT/14/2003

Clifton Rd, Bangor

Validity of notice

Tenant

Description; waiver;  service

Skelton v McEvoy (2)

BTO96

[2003] 8/72

BT/72/2001

Antrim Rd, Belfast

Costs

Calderbank

Experts' conduct

Foyleside v DSG Retail

BTO96

[2003] 8/71

BT/75/2003

Forestside, Belfast

Agreement to surrender

Offer back clause

Wong & Anr v Jan (1)

BTO96

[2004] 3/77

BT/18/2003

Glen Rd, Belfast

Opposition

Own use

Intention; break clause

O'Hora & Anr v Bridgewater Academy Ltd

BTO96

[2005]

BT/27/2005

Wellington Pk, Belfast

Opposition

Rent

Wong & Anr v Jan (2)

BTO96

[2005] 7/90

BT/18/2003

Glen Rd, Belfast

Duration

Discretion

McLean v Scottish Provident

BTA64

[1989]

BT/80/1986

Donegall Sq West, Belfast

Terms

Service charges

Institutional lease

Co-op Chemists v Johnson & Anr

BTO96

[2005] 8/63

BT/69/2004

Ballygomartin Rd, Belfast

Duration

Tenant's option to break

Mo & Anr v Bamford & Sons

BTO96

[2006] 8/65

BT/19/2000

Saintfield Rd, Belfast

Compensation

Costs

Timing; causation; withdrawal

Gough & Ors v Jermon

BTO96

[2007] 6/71

BT/35/2007

Great Victoria St, Belfast

Costs

Jurisdiction

Transitional provisions

Offodum & Anr v NIHE

BTO96

[2008] 1/51

BT/5/2006

Andersonstown Rd, Belfast

Costs

Conduct

Munchies v McCay Properties

BTO96

[2008] 8/69

BT/26/2005

Castle Pl, Strabane

Interim Rent

Costs

Capita v BBC

BTO96

[2008] 9/73

BT/57/2006

Great Victoria St, Belfast

Agreement to Surrender

Outsourcing

Cameron & Ors v Gordon & Ors

BTA64

[1970]

BT/11/1966

Fortwilliam Golf Club, Downview Av, Belfast

Improvements

Rent

Duration

Boots v Belfast Office Properties

BTO96

[2008] 8/68

BT/44 & 45/2007

Ards Shopping Centre, Newtownards

Tenancy application

Application to amend

DX Services v Belfast International Airport

BTO96

[2009] 2/84

BT/4/2007

Belfast International Airport

Improvements

Rent

Cheung & Anr v Fernheath

BTO96

[2009] 6/69

BT/55/2007

Whitewell Rd, Newtownabbey

Costs

Withdrawal

Tarwood v Giordano & Anr (1)

BTO96

[2010] 5/32

BT/38 & 39/2009

Ormeau Av, Belfast

Opposition

Intention

Own use

Short Title

Principal Act or Order

BNIL Citation or Year

Lands Tribunal Reference

Property Location

Main Issue

Other or Subsidiary Issue

Significant Other Issues or Legislation

Flanagan v COV

RO77

[1990] 10/54

VR/19/1988

Glen Rd, Belfast

End allowance

Nuisances

Taggart v COV

RO77

[1990] 2/75

VR/6/1989

Sharman Cl, Belfast

Temporary allowance

Too transient

Maria Upholstery v COV

RO77

[1990] 3/107

VR/32/1988

Carrickfergus Marina

Industrial relief

Retail

Glenavna Hotel v COV

RO77

[1990] 5/82

VR/30/1988

Shore Rd, Newtownabbey

Personal application

Withdrawal

Brown v COV

RO77

[1990] 5/83

VR/22/1989

Thorndale Rd Sth, Carryduff

End allowance

Blow-downs

Millings v COV

RO77

[1990] 8/52

VR/29/1989

Smithfield Sq, Belfast

Temporary allowance

Nicholl v COV

RO77

[1990] 9/75

VR/7/1989

Garnerville Pk, Belfast

End allowance

Noise

Patrick McCartan v COV

RO77

[1991] 1/85

VR/48/1987

Main St, Donaghcloney

Liquor licence

Receipts & expenditure

Actual;  hypothetical

Irish World v COV

RO77

[1991] 2/78

VR/14/1990

Market Sq, Dungannon

Exemption

Use

Marks & Spencer v COV

RO77

[1991] 3/102

VR/30/1986

Donegall Pl, Belfast

Date of assessment

State & circumstances

Validity of certificate

Fletcher v COV

RO77

[1991] 3/104

VR/18/1990

Milford Av, Dunmurry

End allowance

Electricity pole

Jordan v COV

RO77

[1991] 7/146

VR/17/1990

Church Lane, Belfast

Unit

Upper floors

Hagan v COV

RO77

[1991] 7/147

VR/29/1990

Killaughey Rd Sth, Co Down

Valuation

Disrepair

Burden

Lofty Inns Ltd v COV

RO77

[1991] 7/98

VR/31/1986

Clarence St, Belfast

Tone of the List

Receipts & expenditure

McKeown Vintners v COV

RO77

[1991] 8/70

VR/9/1985

Shaftesbury Sq, Belfast

Tone of the List

Off-licence

Toos of comparison;  receipts & expenditure;  no automatic enhancement

Samuel Monteith v COV

RO77

[1991] 9/87

VR/1/1991

Main St, Castlederg

Burden

Wheely-bin

Leckpatrick Dairies v COV

RO77

[1992] 4/88

VR/22/1990 & VR/23/1990

Art Rd, Strabane

Industrial relief

Unit

Contiguity

Samuel Stevenson v COV

RO77

[1992] 5/102

VR/18/1989

Annesborough, Craigavon

Industrial

Balance sheet

Primacy; overturned on appeal see [1993] 2/107 & [1992] NILR 258

Susan E Simpson v COV

RO77

[1992] 7/68

VR/1/1992

Rathfriland Rd, Dromara

End allowance

Damp

Smoke pollution

Geddis Enterprises v COV

RO77

[1992] 8/67

VR/13/1990

Young St, Lisburn

Industrial relief

Unit

Contiguity

Behzadafshar v COV

RO77

[1992] 8/68

VR/7/1992

Queen St, Belfast

Valuation

Comparables

Pattern

Chambers v COV

RO77

[1994] 1/79

VR/21/1993

Broomhill Rd, Spa

End allowance

Valuation date

Smell

O'Neill v COV

RO77

[1994] 1/79

VR/13/1993

The Grange, Lurgan

Temporary allowance

Unfinished road

Leckey v COV

RO77

[1994] 10/88

VR/2/1994

Ardmillan, Belfast

Flat

Comparables

Category of property

Glenkeen Orange Hall v COV

RO77

[1994] 10/89

VR/31/1993

Aghadoey, Coleraine

Rural hall

Class affected

Tone of the List

Conway v COV

RO77

[1994] 3/68

VR/5/1991

Chapel St, Cookstown

Burden

Comparables

Security base

McGarvey v COV

RO77

[1994] 3/69

VR/14/1992

Birch Grove, Cookstown

Burden

Comparables

Traffic

Harland & Wolff v COV

RO77

[1994] 3/70

VR/25/1990

Dee St, Belfast

Relief

Recreation

Part;  ballroom

Troughton v COV

RO77

[1994] 4/71

VR/22/1993

Crievelaugh Rd, Dungannon

End allowance

Special drawbacks

Dwelling;  extended and redeveloped

Gorman v COV

RO77

[1994] 7/92

VR/26/1993

Greyabbey

Temporary allowance

Unmade roads

Hypothetical tenant

Coyle v COV

RO77

[1994] 7/93

VR/2, 3 & 4/1993

Ballintrain Rd, Carrickmore

End allowance

Privacy

Noise; RUC station; fresh grounds; burden;  pre-existing pattern;  scope of cross examination

Newtownards Chronicle v COV

RO77

[1995] 10/75

VR/4/1992

Frances St, Newtownards

Industrial relief

Article

Manual labour

Robinson v COV

RO77

[1995] 10/76

VR/10/1993

Mallusk, Newtownabbey

Industrial relief

Bulk

Primacy

Laginaf v COV

RO77

[1995] 7/61

VR/1/1995

Glen Rd, Holywood

End allowance

Site size

Drainage;  finish and construction

NI Transport Holding Co v COV

RO77

[1996] 8/98

VR/9/1993

St Andrew's Sq, Belfast

Valuation method

Hybrid

Comparative; receipts & expenditure; expert's duty; admissiblity of accounts

Harron v COV

RO77

[1997] 6/116

VR/10/1994

Lisburn Rd, Belfast

Industrial relief

Retail

Primary purpose

Granville Cold Storage v COV

RO77

[1998] 10/79

VR/4/1995

Granville Industrial Estate, Dungannon

Industrial relief

Storage

Burden

Knights of St Columbanus v COV

RO77

[1998] 7/66

VR/3/1996

York Lane, Belfast

Exemption

Objects

Religious purposes;  church hall

Larne Enterprise Co v COV

RO77

[1998] 9/54

VR/6/1995

Bank Rd, Larne

Exemption

Objects

Profit;  costs

Newry Building Supplies Ltd v COV

RO77

[1999] 6/93

VR/8/1997

Rampart Rd

Industrial relief

Retail

Primacy of trade

Boyde v COV

RO77

[2000] 2/84

VR/24/1999

Greystone Pk, Coleraine

End allowance

Nuisance

Anderson v COV

RO77

[2000] 8/57

VR/15/2000

Bryansburn Gdns, Bangor

End allowance

Expert evidence

Self represented persons; transparency; duty of expert

Northern Bank v COV

RO77

[2000] 9/59

VR/117/1999

Donegall Sq West, Belfast

End allowance

Access

Hypothetical tenant; expert evidence

Queen's University v COV (1)

RO77

[2000] 9/60

VR/51/1998

Stranmillis Gdns, Belfast

Relief

Recreation

Purpose; use; education

War Memorial Hostel v COV

RO77

[2001] 4/86

VR/124/1999

Derryvolgie Av, Belfast

Exemption

Objects

Use; church hall; religious purposes;  unit

Black v COV

RO77

[2002] 3/100

VR/4/1998

Kingsgate St, Coleraine

Valuation

Zoning

Disrepair; expert evidence

Brennan v COV

RO77

[1994]

VR/33/1993

Culmore, Londonderry

End allowance

Nuisance

Burden;  comparables;  revaluation

Queen's University v COV (2)

RO77

[2002]

VR/51/1998

Stranmillis Gdns, Belfast

Leave to amend Statement of Case

Finality of decision

Queen's University v COV (3)

RO77

[2002]

VR/51/1998

Stranmillis Gdns, Belfast

Exemption

Purpose

Costs

Kennedy Entertainments v COV

RO77

[2002] 9/72

VR/27/2000

Kerr St, Portrush

Valuation

Valuation method

Receipts & expenditure;  category of use; tone of the list;  helpfulness of comparables

A-wear v COV

RO77

[2003] 6/93

VR/3/2001

The Quays, Newry

Valuation

State and circumstances of comparables at relevant time

Comparables under challenge

Milliken v COV

RO77

[2005]

VR/1/2004

The Hill, Groomsport

Comparisons

Services

Wilson v COV

RO77

[2006] 9/99

VR/7/2005

Ballynahinch Rd, Dromore

Occupation Farmer

Reversed on Appeal

Corr/Moy Riding School v COV

RO77

[2006]

VR/28 & 30/2000

Derrycaw Rd, Dungannon

Unit of Assessment

Shared use

Valuation

Drummond v COV

RO77

[2003] 2/98

VR/24/2002

Drumsurn Rd, Limavady

Recreation Relief

Professional Coach

Flannigan v COV

RO77

[2008] 10/100

VT/1/2008

Corernagh Rd, Tandragee

Leave

Serious doubt

General importance

Odyssey v COV

RO77

[2010]

VR/2/2006

Queens Quay, Belfast

Charitable Relief

Recreational Charities Act (NI) 1958 

Short Title

Principal Act or Order

BNIL Citation or Year

Lands Tribunal Reference

Property Location

Main Issue

Other or Subsidiary Issue

Significant Other Issues or Legislation

Bradley v COV

RO72

[1965]

VR/49/1965

Urney Rd, Strabane

Valuation

Repairs

O'Doherty v COV

RO72

[1965]

VR/73/1965

Railway St, Strabane

Valuation

Comparables

Campbell v COV

RO72

[1965]

VR/69/1965

Prince Edward Pk, Belfast

End allowance

Nuisance

Robinson v COV

RO72

[1965]

VR/77/1965

Gortmore Dr, Omagh

End allowance

Privacy

Ginniff v COV

RO72

[1965]

VR/75/1965

Church Rd, Newtownbreda

End allowance

Privacy

Carvill v COV

RO72

[1966]

VR/52/1965

Ballyedmond, Killowen, Kilkeel

Valuation

Amenities

Comparables

McBrien v COV

RO72

[1966]

VR/12/1966

Hillsborough Dr, Belfast

Valuation

Nuisance

Neighbour

Shillington v COV

RO72

[1966]

VR/10/1966

Belfast Rd, Craigavad

End allowance

Privacy

Disabilities

Shillington v COV

RO72

[1966]

VR/9/1966

Belfast Rd, Craigavad

End allowance

Privacy

Hawthorne v COV

RO72

[1967]

VR/48/1967

Rosepark Central, Dundonald

End allowance

Privacy

Comparables

Victoria Housing Estates v COV

RO77

[1968]

VR/50/1967

Clonaver Dr, Belfast

Lease restrictions

Comparables

Carrick v COV

RO77

[1968]

VR/6/1968

Wheatfield Gdns, Belfast

End allowance

Neighbour

Johnston v COV

RO77

[1968]

VR/59-61/1968

Clanbrassil Rd, Co Down

End allowance

Neighbour

Access

Hull v COV

RO77

[1969]

VR/62/1968

Saintfield Rd, Belfast

Valuation

Garage

Crotty v COV

RO77

[1969]

VR/58/1968

Lisdrumliska, Newry

Valuation

Comparables

Stories

Kemplay v COV

RO77

[1969]

VR/21/1969

Woodland Pk, Lisburn

End allowance

Traffic

Privacy

O'Kane & Anr v COV

RO77

[1970]

VR/10 & 11/1969

Bridge St, Strabane

End allowance

Traffic

Neighbour

Patterson v COV

RO77

[1970]

VR/22/1969

Dunbreen, Omagh

Valuation

Services

Comparables

Norton v COV

RO77

[1970]

VR/5/1970

Algeo Dr, Enniskillen

End allowance

View

Bailey v COV

RO77

[1970]

VR/21/1970

Belmont Church Rd, Belfast

End allowance

Neighbour

Nuisance

McConnell v COV

RO77

[1972]

VR/28/1971

Old Holywood Rd, Holywood

End allowance

Neighbour

Noise

Gibson v COV

RO77

[1972]

VR/9/1972

Mount Pleasant Rd, Newtownabbey

Valuation

Flooding

Comparables

Stewart v COV

RO77

[1972]

VR/6/1972

Dergalt, Strabane

End allowance

Services

McCullough v COV

RO77

[1972]

VR/23/1972

Downshire Rd, Newry

End allowance

Neighbour

Nuisance

Troughton v COV

RO77

[1973]

VR/4/1973

Ballintaggart, Portadown

Valuation

Comparables

Burden

O'Connor v COV

RO77

[1974]

VR/8/1974

Ballyoran Heights, Craigavon

Valuation

Location

Nuisance

Johnston v COV

RO77

[1975]

VR/9/1974

Dunluce Pk, Ballymena

Valuation

Junction box

McMaster v COV

RO77

[1975]

VR/2/1975

Church Rd, Castlereagh

End allowance

Privacy

Smyth & Ors v COV

RO77

[1976]

VR/17-19/1975

Netherleigh Pk, Belfast

End allowance

Security lighting

Privacy

Sherrard v COV

RO77

[1976]

VR/3/1976

O'Neill Rd, Newtownabbey

End allowance

Traffic

Burden

Johnston v COV

RO77

[1976]

VR/12/1976

Coastguard Rd, Larne

End allowance

Nuisance

Burden

Lawlor v COV

RO77